technovelty

weblog of Ian Wienand

RSS  |  technovelty home  |  page of ian  |  ian@wienand.org

Grace Wifi Radio Review

I recently purchased a Grace ITC-IR1000 Wifi Radio from Beach Audio.

Grace ITC-IR1000 Wifi Radio

There seem to be a number of competing products available at the moment, and it seems they are all based on the Reciva internet radio platform. This appears to be an ARM based system running Linux (checkout the GPL compliance area).

It has built-in wireless, so connects up directly to your 802.11 network. It supports WEP and WPA; entering the WPA key is a little like entering your high score on an arcade game with a built-in scrolling alphabet. It supports all sorts of codecs, including the most important Real, WMA and MP3.

Once on the network, it contacts Reciva service (free) to update and download channel lists. Once there, you can select stations filtered by region (Europe, Oceania, etc) then country. There are literally thousands to choose from, and users can contribute streams which are filtered by Reciva and added to the database periodically. An excellent feature is the ability to log-in to the website and both build favourite lists and add your own personal streams. You then register your radio's serial number with the website and on the next channel update you get access to your lists.

It also offers you the opportunity to connect to a local PC to stream music from folders there; I haven't looked into this feature at all.

Overall, it's a great device. The audio quality is great, and it seems to have at least a little sub-woofer built in. It has some nice features; 5 of the buttons on the front are quick access preset buttons, just hold it down when you are listening to the station and it remembers it. It supports a wide range of streams, the interface is simple to understand, it keeps the clock via NTP and directly connecting to the wireless is great.

My ideal application is for a bedside clock radio, so I can listen to .au radio as I go to sleep and wake up. It has an inbuilt back-lit clock, sleep timer and alarm system, but they all take a bit of fiddling. The buttons are small and black, which doesn't help in the dark, and most access is done via the big scroll wheel which you press to make a selection (think iPod). However, the resistance of the rubber pads is less than that the pressure required to push the button in, so it really takes two hands. This means when you want to setup an alarm and put on the sleep timer as you go to bed there is a bit of fiddling through menus, etc. Also, as it is playing the clock seems to go away. Initially I had a problem with firewall ports, but it doesn't seem a big issue on the forums so it must have just been me.

I also wonder what happens when Reciva go out of business, because all the tuning happens via their website. Something similar happened when 3com Audrey support was dropped; it then became a matter of faking DNS replies. Sniffing the protocol might be fun :)

All in all, although it sounds a little silly, if you know what you want it for this is a great little system. I imagine any expat will get their money's worth listening to home radio stations. If you're only interested in local radio, I'd still suggest the best thing is still probably (surprise, surprise) a radio. It leaves a little to be desired as a bedside radio but is otherwise a very nice toy!

2009-02-20 This has turned out to be one of the more popular things I have ever posted, so I should provide an update. There have been several firmware updates released with a range of new features, the most notable being able to hook up to Pandora and Sirius.

Other than that, there have been some nice updates such as allowing the wireless to stay connected in the background, reducing the time between turning on and getting radio sounds out, and a few display updates like displaying the time while radio is playing.

I have played around a bit more with the local media streaming; I found it quite unintuitive and difficult to use. I set up my entire MP3 collection as a Samaba share and pointed the radio at it, but it choked scanning the directory and the few thousand files. I found the only practical way was to setup a separate share with just a few things in it and create a .m3u playlist. Trying to navigate through many songs on the little screen just isn't great.

posted at: Fri, 21 Mar 2008 22:43 | in /toys | permalink | add comment (9 others)

Posted by Qatar Boy at Tue Sep 23 16:59:34 2008

I got this radio a couple of weeks ago and I absolutely love it. It was breeze to set up and I do hope that it will have longer life than my Roku which died after less than a month. No complaints so far.

Posted by Richard at Wed Dec 24 03:00:24 2008

The one deficiency radio is its onboard memories -- only 5.  By comparison the CC Wifi has 99 onboard memories.

So I recommend people get a radio with as many onboard memories as possible, everything else being equal.

That means Reciva could cease operations and you could still tune 99 stations (as long as their URLs hadn't changed).

Posted by Ken at Wed Jan 21 12:17:34 2009

I think it's a wonderful sounding unit, the lack of more presets is a short coming but overall it's a great sounding unit. The buttons are lacking in the dark but if your just going to sleep with it on it shouldnt matter much.

Posted by Rob at Fri Jan 23 05:45:50 2009

I would agree with having more on board memories. It would be make this device that much better.

Posted by Bob Eveslage at Fri Feb 20 04:59:02 2009

I've had my Grace Wifi radio for about four months now, and absolutely love it!!!  I had no problem setting it up, and use it for the Reciva stations as well as my own streams.

My only 'complaint' is the lack of front panel memories....only five.  However, you can select the 'list' easily and access any of 99 stations in the 'My Stations' or 'My Streams' mode.  The system sounds great bedside and through my pillow speaker or a good side of bedside computer speakers.  I can choose either.  No more summer storm static (QRN) or fading (QSB).  I can listen to my favorite AM stations (or FM) from around the world.  I easily filled most of my memories with the music and talk radio I could possible ever need.

My only concern was, of course, the stability of Reciva as a company.  I hope they stay in business, as I'd hate to see the radio go obsolete.  I don't think that would happen, however, as too many folks depend on Reciva and even if the company changed hands we should be able to keep listening.

I'm sold on Wifi radio.  Now that I've tried it I couldn't live without it!!!

Posted by Valerie at Mon Mar 23 05:01:07 2009

I liked my Grace ITC-IR1000 at first.  However, I am having trouble connecting to 3 favorite stations.  I keep getting a "connecting" and "retrying" loop that goes continually when I try to get my favs.  Does anyone know how to get around this?  I just bought and and had the radio set up by a Comcast Tech so I know nothing about what to do.  Be kind, I am very new at this.  Thanx.

Posted by Charles Jefts at Tue Jul 7 02:31:42 2009

I have no problems with the 5 memory buttons. I never use them. I simply press "reply" while listening to a station I like. The radio fetches a menu and I can add the station to my favorites. Shows up on the web site also. The number of favorites seems to be unlimited. Then go to my stuff/my stations to access again.

Posted by Diane Fields at Fri Aug 21 05:46:40 2009

Valerie, I'm guessing that the stations you listen to may have server issues.  If you know what they are, why don't you check out their website and see if they are having issues.  I would also suggest you unplug and replug--reboot, IOW.

You might try the Grace site and through them Reciva.  If your other stations are coming in, they I would suggest you try other stations--use the volume knob and back button and check out the menus (reading the manual will help a lot--its pretty straightforward as long as you have no connectivy issues with your own router)

Posted by steve at Wed May 19 08:16:05 2010

Alright......  ....I'm looking at this model vs the CC Wifi.  I would love suggestions at ok_blessed@yahoo.com

thanks

Add a comment
*Name
*Email (not shown)
Website
*Comment:
Anti-spam:
* denotes required field

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 2.5 License.